For example, abelard s book sic et non yes and no 1122 set the stage for discussing the relationship between faith and reason in christian theology. There is no more connection between the goodness of the intention and the goodness of the deed than. Abelard, peter internet encyclopedia of philosophy. In view of these considerations, i have ventured to bring together various dicta of the holy fathers, as they came to mind, and to formulate certain questions which were suggested by the seeming contradictions in the statements. Cousins collection gave extracts from the theological work sic et non yes and no which is an assemblage of what abelard saw as opposite opinions on doctrinal points culled from the fathers as a basis for discussion. An enormous german website about abelard and heloise provides a map showing all the places relevant to their personal histories. While at st denis he wrote a textbook entitled sic et non, yes and no or on one hand and on the other in which he listed 158 questions concerning contradictions in the writings of the church fathers and other classical authorities. What is sic et non definition of sic et non word finder. He is mainly associated with the dominant medieval movement of scholasticism. Radice, elizabeth, 1974, the letters of abelard and heloise, new york. Petrus abaelardus oder kurz abaelard, latinisiert aus pierre abaillard 1079 in le pallet bei.
Get updates from sic et non delivered straight to your inbox. Responsibility translated from the latin by priscilla throop. Peter abelard was born in the small town of le pallet in 1079 the eldest son of minor breton nobility. Since then, another full ms and eight fragments have come to light.
What examples does abelard cite of scripture being questioned in the past. Our respect for their authority should not stand in the way of an effort on our part to come at the truth. History of christianity i part 2 flashcards quizlet. Abelard s sic et non presents 158 theological questions, followed by citations from various church fathers, councils, and creeds. Sic et non, excerpts, at internet archive, from clinch valley college. In view of these considerations, i have ventured to bring. A dialogue of a philosopher with a jew and a christian, toronto. In sic et non, abelard presents 158 questions that present a theological assertion and allows its negation.
Historia calamitatum internet history sourcebooks project. Gildas, details abelard s rise to fame and the misfortunes of his fall. They advocate a discriminating, not to say suspicious, use of the writings of their own contemporaries. Perhaps the most important of these is peter lombard, whose book of sentences, modeled on abelard s sic et non, contains many of abelard s opinions and became the primary text for training theologians during the next four hundred years. The historia, written after abelard s escape from st.
Abelard then sent heloise back to her home in argenteuil, where this letter may have been written. Among his works is sic et non, a list of 158 philosophical and theological questions. Prologue to sic et non internet history sourcebooks project. The obscurity and contradictions in ancient writings may be explained upon many grounds. Also, send me the latterday saint newsletter and special offers. In it he explained how the meaning of words develops over time and how apparent contradictions can be reconciled. In sic et non, abelard presents 158 questions that present a theological. Yes and no the complete english translation of peter. Abelards sic et non presents 158 theological questions, followed by citations from various church fathers, councils, and creeds. The given article presents a philosophical analysis of medieval love through the prism of abelard s antagonism, sic et non the medieval contradiction of the spheres of the ancestral and the individual in human life, love eros and love agape is considered. Martinus nijhoff 1975, 225228 peter king sic et non ed. Dl belong to an intermediate recension of the sic et non, which likewise dates to the period 11211126.
Without claiming to be exhaustive, this article will focus on the methodological principles that abelard introduces in. Peter abelard and the development of scholasticism by. Sic et non, an early scholastic text whose title translates from medieval latin as yes and. Peter abelard 10791142 was one of the great intellectuals of the 12th century, with especial importance in the field of logic. Miscellanea patristica, historica et liturgica eligio dekkers o. A critical edition english and latin edition peter abailard, boyer, blanche beatrice, mckeon, richard peter on. Read, highlight, and take notes, across web, tablet, and phone. Pearce williams, great issues in western civilization, 3rd ed. Pierre peter abelard, introduction and short biography. Justice has sufficient authority without wisdom, but wisdom without. Sic et non, an early scholastic text whose title translates from medieval latin as yes and no, was written by peter abelard.
Sic et non was the second of abelard s theological works, composed in successive redactions in the few years that followed the condemnation at soissons, in 1121, of the theologia summi. A critical edition, university of chicago press 1977. Peter abelard by individual philosopher philosophy. You can read the latin prologue to sic et non online. It also provides a number of other texts online, including excerpts from his sic et non with a sample manuscript page. Pierre abelard april 21, 1079 1142 was a medieval french scholastic, theologian, and preeminent logician. In the prologue, abelard outlines rules for reconciling these contradictions, the most important of which is noting the. Abelard s sic et non yes and no juxtaposed apparently contradictory statements by authorities of comparable stature, pitting one church father against another. Also, by pointing out that established authorities often conflicted, abelard called attention to the fact that they needed to be sorted out, clarified and reconciled. Johannes stelzenberger, conscientia bei augustinus, paderborn 1959, s. Mkak belong to the latest recension of the sic et non, which dates to the period 112712. The outline of abelard s career is well known, largely because he.
Peter abelard 10791142 was a french philosopher, considered one of the greatest thinkers of the 12th century, though his teachings were controversial, and he was repeatedly charged with heresy. His book, sic et non, still stands as an early attempt to combine church theology and logic, and can be seen as a precursor to the work of theologians such as aquinas. There are many seeming contradictions and even obscurities in the innumerable writings of the church fathers. Yes and no the complete english translation of peter abelard s sic et non book. Peter abelard french theologian and poet britannica. Several wellknown masters also turned to abelard as a significant thinker. Prologue to sic et non that whenever the word that is. The scholastic method in medieval education professor roger. Career as a monk findings in a compilation entitled sic et non yes and no. Peter abelard, french theologian and philosopher best known for his solution of the problem of universals and for his original use of dialectics. He continued to see her, however, and the uncle ultimately had abelard castrated to prevent him entering the church.
In sic et non, he juxtaposed passages from scripture and the opinions of the early church fathers on both sides of 158 theological issues. What scandalized some readers was abelard s failure to resolve these contradictions. Sic et non project gutenberg selfpublishing ebooks. Peter abelard, sic et non yes and no among the multitudinous words of the holy fathers some sayings seem not only to differ from one another but even to contradict one another. Abelard s best known writings are his autobiography the historia calamitatum the story of my misfourtunes, the letters he exchanged with heloise, and the sic et non. According to abelard, what can happen if we do not doubt and question. Peter abelard s sic et non lay in obscurity until the 19th century, when victor cousin discovered a full manuscript and a fragment.
Abelard s major work was the sic et non yes and no, a collection of quotations from the bible and the church fathers that showed support for both sides of theological questions. Abelard s theological works include sic et non, consisting of scriptural and patristic passages arranged for. His tendency to disputation is perhaps best demonstrated by his book sic et non, a list of 158 philosophical and theological questions about which there were divided opinions. Sic et non yes and no a list of quotations from christian authorities on philosophical and theological questions. Peter king 2007 american catholic philosophical quarterly 81 2. The pontifical institute of mediaeval studies publications. Sic et non des petrus abaelard, 11221123 geschrieben, ist ein. Priscilla throop perhaps his most important contribution to philosophy and theology is the method which he developed in his sic et non yea and nay, a method germinally contained in the teaching of his. Rather than offering a reconciliation of the conflicting positions, abelard let the contradictions stand, allegedly to stimulate careful thinking. You are tending the vineyard of anothers vine which you did. When abelard discovered that there was no debate but instead a.
In the work, abelard juxtaposes apparently contradictory quotations from the church fathers on many of the traditional topics of christian theology. Our respect for their authority should not stand in. Sic et non zynismus oder eine didaktisch verwertbare methode. Download download sic et non pdf form read online read online sic et non pdf form sic et non a critical edition peter abelard yes and no pdf sic et non was an effort to demonstrate that et non translation what is sic et non about.
1073 648 625 322 112 1567 1071 862 1272 76 666 492 9 279 118 487 1059 1542 1502 501 1006 447 1002 308 334 796 1325 1431 1399 792 752 1444 239 314 955 705 635 23 1440 1397 1099 279